Story first appeared in the Detroit Free Press.
least 146,000 Michiganders — and possibly thousands more — with health
coverage purchased directly from insurers now are learning their polices
will end Dec. 31 because they don’t meet the minimum requirements of
the federal health care act.
Under the law, each policy must
cover essential benefits in 10 categories. Instead of beefing up these
policies, insurers are opting to drop them, advising consumers to
consider other policies that are now available either from the insurers
directly or though the Michigan Health Insurance Marketplace, also known
as the state exchange.
The policies that are ending were often
less expensive on the individual market because they provided limited
benefits and were sold to healthier consumers.
And that was fine with consumers such as Josh Mulder.
had landed a plan several years ago that cost his Wixom family offour
just $291 a month. That policy will end Dec. 31, according to a letter
from his insurer.
The policy didn’t cover things such as
maternity care or prescription drugs, but, Mulder said, his family is
generally healthy and he was willing to take the risk.
“I had a great rate,” he said.
that meet the required benefits under health reform average $762.06 a
month on the Michigan Health Insurance Marketplace for his family of
four, according to a cost estimator by the Michigan Department of
Insurance and Financial Services.
Blue Cross Blue Shield of
Michigan has notified about 140,000 policyholders on the individual
market that their plans will end Dec. 31. Health Alliance Plan and its
subsidiaries are dropping 6,000 plans.
Both are major players on
the state exchange, where 13 insurers, including a HAP subsidiary and
another Blues insurer, Blue Care Network, are offering 142 plans.
Blue Cross and HAP are ending current policies on the individual market
isn’t surprising, said Robert Krughoff, founder and president of the
Washington-based nonprofit Consumer Checkbook.
costs to provide essential benefits was just one part of the cost
equation. Under the health care reform law, insurers also can’t deny
anyone insurance, even if they’re very sick. Neither can insurers cut
cap coverage at a lifetime limit.
“These plans had to be reconfigured,” Krughoff said.
will pay more, but they also will get more coverage now, noted Gail
Jensen Summers, an economics professor at Wayne State University, who
specializes in health insurance policy and costs.
may expect their customers to seek them out on the marketplace, where
federal tax credits for some consumers can help shrink the costs of the
monthly premiums, according to Checkbook’s Krughoff.
In the first
10 days of business, the exchange logged 14.6 million unique visits,
according to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
whose income is up to 400% of the federal poverty limit — up to $45,960
for an individual and $94,200 for a family of four — is eligible for
Health insurance reform supporters have said this
puts insurance within reach for an estimated 1.4 million Michiganders
who are underinsured or uninsured.
Blue Cross, in fact, is competing aggressively on state marketplaces across the U.S., Krughoff said.
insurer on the Michigan exchange, Kentucky-based Humana, indicated that
it, too, will end some policies, but it declined to offer specifics.
Letters to members are being finalized, according to the insurer.
Rapids-based Priority Health is taking a different tack. It’s allowing
its current and new members to lock in 2013 rates that extend through
2014 before they end those plans on Dec. 31, 2014. The plans won’t
include all the essential benefits required under the law, but the
insurer will be able to extend them for one more year, said spokeswoman
That extension is possible for some plans. Still,
with the exception of catastrophic plans targeted for those younger than
30, all plans on the individual market must carry essential benefits
Jan. 1, 2015, said Caleb Buhs, spokesman for the Michigan insurance
Consumers can still find plans on the exchange and
off the exchange that do cover all the essential benefits. It might cost
the insurer more to offer the extension at the same premium rates, but
it gives members “more time to consider their options going into 2015,”
Gary Plasko of Walled Lake is looking at options like those.
insurance broker, he knew big changes were coming under health care
reform. He wasn’t surprised when he was notified last week that his
policy — one that costs the 63-year-old nonsmoker $381 a month and
covered about 70% of his medical costs with no deductible — was ending.
And he had warned customers to expect similar notices.
Still, he was disappointed with what he found.
Like the Mulders, Plasko won’t get tax credits to help him pay for the new policies.
said he found a Blue Cross policy for less than $550, but it covers
about 60% of his medical costs. Plus, he now faces a $6,350 deductible.
The law? For him, he said, “it’s the un-Affordable Care Act.”